• The Truth Behind LED TVs

    The Truth Behind LED TVs

    Roydon Cerejo, Nov 10, 2010 1121 hrs IST

    We find out if it's actually worth the high price or is it better to wait

    mail share

    next

LED backlighting in TVs has been a real boon for end users, while manufactures have been able to create stunningly slim televisions. It also keeps the environmentalists happy since there is no mercury used in LED backlit TVs there by giving you a greener product. We tested quite a few LED based LCD TVs in the past and the difference in power consumption is certainly visible while still maintaining a good brightness level.

The problem with the term "LED backlit LCD" is that it's a bit too long, which does not look good in advertisements and posters. Manufacturers have conveniently eliminated LCD and simply highlight "LED", duping customers into thinking they are LED TVs, which they clearly aren't. Today we'll have a look at the different types of LED LCD TVs currently available that offer improved picture quality over the other or even traditional LCD TVs.

All LED Backlit TVs are not created equal

The first thing that you should know is that not all LED LCD TVs are created equal. Just because the TV may have a sticker that says "LED" on it does not mean you'll get the same performance as the flagship model. Stop and think for a moment, if companies used the same technologies in their high-end and low-end products, no one would look at the higher end models, right?



There are predominantly two types of LED backlighting technologies; Edge-lit LEDs and Full array LEDs. The first batch of LED TVs that came out in 2009 were based on this technology and was first showcased by Samsung. Today you'll find everyone using this technology in their "cheaper" LED LCD TVs. Edge-lit typically means the LEDs are placed around the edge, which allow companies to make slimmer TVs. There are no major advantages in this type of LED LCD over conventional LCDs when it comes to picture quality. In fact there are many uniformity issues with edge-lit LEDs, like certain areas of the TV tend to be brighter than others, which we noticed when we reviewed the Sony ZX1. This is cheaper to produce than Full array LED LCDs, since they use a fewer number of LEDs.

The other technology that can be found on most of high-end TVs of today is Full array LEDs. As the name suggests, there is a full array of LEDs (see pic) sitting behind the LCD panel. This obviously gives you a more even backlighting with little or no uniformity issues. Mid-range to high end models typically have this sort of backlighting, like the Samsung UNC6500 series. In terms of picture quality, there is no real perceptible difference when compared to an LCD. The only advantage here is lower power consumption and again a slimmer profile. The latest crop of LED LCD TVs feature Local Dimming LED technology, which changes the game altogether. 


Follow Techtree on Twitter

    next

Do you agree with this article?
YesNo

Up

83

Down

4



Discussion Board
(44) Comments
Mike
,California, on Dec 04, 2011 12:58 PM
I am suffering from (mild) eye inflammation with sony LED LCD newly got KDL46HX729 - sitting 11+ feet away. Got checked with eye doctor. May have mild scleritis. Anyone else got this problem or any input? Thinking of changing to LCD or Plasma TV .. I am used to LCD monitor so hoping that is better on eye.
Satish Shukla
,Panipat, on Sep 25, 2011 06:37 PM
very educative article, eye opening....hahaha,,good work guys..thanks a lot
Aniruddh
,Ahmedabad, on Dec 18, 2010 02:59 PM
well that's true that Plasma take power much but companies not showing the reality picture to consumers. It consumes the power much compared to LCD/LED but also less consumes then the CRT TVs so if u had CRT and that time u was okay with your power bill then i think nothing to worry. it's just companies try to sell higher end products like 3D LEDs? the 3D phenomena is a total fail...3D TV, Mobiles, 3D Games, nobody wants to have a each pare of glasses for each person to watch the 3D TV. imagine if you're hosting a cricket part at your home with 8 to 10 pals so how many 3D glasses u gonna need and each gonna cost at least 10,000 each! the fact is LCD/LED only good if u watching atleast a 10 or 12 feet distance . as u near to the tv set so you'll fed up with your eyes and ur eyes gonna tired very fast. in plasma this thing is not gonna happen as it produce natural color via gas in content instead of LED/LCD which produced added color to enhanced the content to make it bright and sharp and that's why people eyes are getting tired. In Plasma just don't take a set which having a added another layer of glass on it. LG having both kind of product, with top glass n without top glass layer and due to this top glass would reflect the light from a window or direct light and reflation gonna spoil ur viewing angle .
jitu
,delhi, on Dec 02, 2010 04:35 PM
10 out off 10.
Parag
,Pune, on Nov 11, 2010 11:13 PM
thank god somebody is there who speaks the truth. Its utter non sense to buy LED TV. Forget even the blurriness LCD TV have; its the property of LCD, how can an LCD cannot have motion blur. manufacturer put tag of 100Hz an what not. these manufactures making an handicap run a marathon. Just for comparison that some LED TV with 100 Hz or little extra Hz cost around 1 lac; but a hell lot cheaper plasma runs at 600Hz drive!!!
Nick
,Sweden, on Dec 02, 2010 02:26 PM
You dont seem to know what you're talking about. The refreshrate of plasmas arent 600hz, its 50-100 sometimes 200, same as led/lcd.. the sub motion rate is 600hz, and has been for quite a while, this makes no difference what so ever..
arun
,chennai, on Dec 02, 2010 02:17 PM
excellent!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! PLASMA is anyday better than the best of lcd/led. WARNING: DO NOT GO BY SALESMANS GIMMICKS. STICK TO PLASMA.
simmash
,Bangalore, on Nov 11, 2010 01:50 PM
I just bought Plasma in Aug-2010. The Panasonic Viera series plasma performs way better than any LCD in 50% more price range. A 42" plasma goes for 40K today. It gives perfect black better than any LCD, decent power consumption and same weight/thickness as LCD. My next TV is going to be OLED or full array LED whenever it comes. For the time being I am more than satisfed with 42" plasma.
Dev
,Hyderabad, on Dec 02, 2010 12:30 PM
I agree with Simmash...I have also bought the Panasonic Plasma and trust me, the color contrast, sharpness, smoothness no other LED/LCD tvs can match. Also I observed a problem with LED TVs that if I watch more than an hour, my eyes are getting tired. Having said that, if you go for plasma, install in such a way no direct light falls on the screen, as the top glass layer would reflect the light.
Paul
,Frankston, vic, Aus, on Nov 25, 2010 08:48 PM
There are REAL LED display panels out here, trouble is they are absolutely huge - they are used at concerts and sporting events - ie those massive displays you see on concert stages running all sorts of graphics behind the performers. Also those animated 'strip' displays around the edge of sporting grounds running animated adverts.
Aditya
,Pune, on Nov 17, 2010 11:05 PM
a true LED tv has been developed....... its just 11" and not available commercially....... and of course is exorbitantly costly! its based on AMOLED.
sathish
,chennai, on Nov 23, 2010 04:32 PM
11 inch sony XEL was developed way before in 2006,it was available in US for a whoping price 2500$ ,it was not AMOLED,it's actually passive OLED ...PMOLED.Also latest LG developed a 15 inch commercial OLED tv in korea ,However all the top companies working on developing their own OLED prototypes in every CES shows in LASVEGAS every year.it's not too far that commercial large OLED tv's come to market.By the time these edgelit,CCFL technology become obsolete...
GuRu
,Pune, on Nov 14, 2010 02:43 AM
What about the super amoled displays of samsung?Will they make it to the HDTV? i was quite amazed by their quality n colour on galaxy s.
nik
,mum, on Nov 13, 2010 06:40 PM
Dude this is an awesome article!!! Oh joy!
Haydn
,Brisbane, on Nov 13, 2010 01:13 PM
After my 50" Samsung Plasma Blow a power supply for the second time in 4 years (and out of warranty this time), I went and purchased a Samsung 55" LCD/LED TV. I can say that picture quality is a huge improvement (unfortunitly a lot of tv shows now look to much like stages) The Power consumption is about 5/8 of the cost.
Nishant
,Hyderabad, on Nov 10, 2010 02:33 PM
Maybe people should like at Plasmas as well. They still continue to outperform LEDs this year.
Anoop
,Thrissur, on Nov 10, 2010 06:46 PM
People dont go for Plasma just coz of their ignorance abt that technology. Salesmen usually demotivates prospective plasma buyers. They show the customers LCDs/LEDs playing HD content provided by the manufacturer. Poor customers who are unaware of these facts easily fell into their trap.
Shrutesh
,Mangalore, on Nov 13, 2010 08:00 AM
Plasmas are power hungry monsters..
Samir
,Mumbai, on Nov 12, 2010 02:10 AM
Ok Sorry. Bye bye.
Samir
,Mumbai, on Nov 11, 2010 02:05 AM
Author your such a shmuck! What about power consumption? You don't see that Full LED or LED backlight TV's/Monitor consume less power than traditional CCFL backlit LCD TV's. Not to mention LED backlight offer's better contrast/brightess. Don't know where you get that CCFL backlit produces better image than LED backlight. Yes that would be true if your CCFL backlit LCD panel was IPS & the LED LCD one was TN. I can't believe you advise people to stick with CRT!? Really? Bhai mere agar aap ko rehna hai Baba Azam ke zamane mein toh aap raho, hum toh chale PARDES!
raja
,N Y, on Nov 11, 2010 08:19 AM
i think you didnt read the article ! :p
zzzz
,dilli, on Nov 12, 2010 12:35 AM
well my LCD tv is TN but have mercury lamp, its not LED LCD one :-P
Jazz
,New delhi, on Nov 11, 2010 07:27 PM
Could you pls let me something technical specification about LED television
Ashok
,Bangalore, on Nov 11, 2010 07:03 PM
Good article and well explained
Sally
,Mumbai, on Nov 11, 2010 06:09 PM
Panasonic Viera also has 2 LED LCD models in India but you haven't mentioned them in the article. Do you know if they are local dimming LEDs or not?
Debojit
,New Delhi, on Nov 11, 2010 04:51 PM
@ Roydon : could you suggest which brand to go for ?? I was completely bamboozled by the article..and now I am thinking of getting a Plasma..but still would like your suggestions..any help would be highly appreciated !!
Kshitiz Gupta
,udaipur, on Nov 11, 2010 03:03 PM
Very Good Article.. Now that i know that u shud purchase a LCD than a LED(as of now) can we also knw how to decide which LCD is better,,,
Locav
,Bengaluru, on Nov 10, 2010 11:25 PM
good, unbiased and informative article. I like articles like these... TT should also publish articles that help customer make informed buy.
Kshitiz Gupta
,udaipur, on Nov 11, 2010 03:02 PM
very right...
rahul
,blr, on Nov 11, 2010 02:35 PM
very good article and very informative. You are right LED should cost less but commercial aspect ( R&D ) cost is keeping intial selling at higer price .
Vijay
,Hyderabad, on Nov 11, 2010 01:26 PM
This s really informative, Thanks Roydon :)
Jain
,Bangalore, on Nov 11, 2010 12:26 PM
Very informative for a starter, who is planning to buy an LCD / LED / Plasma and CONFUSED???
Dr. K. A. Rashe
,Manjeri, on Nov 11, 2010 09:56 AM
Great article. Seems to me as a well researched product. I m sure now that my waiting to buy a LCD TV as over. The author has given me very clear ideas about the technology concerned. If a list of LCD Tvs in a tabular form(of various manufacturers) is available (that also include their prices), the readers can analyse this event better.
oled man
,oled land, on Nov 10, 2010 02:11 PM
A word about OLED please?
raja
,N Y, on Nov 11, 2010 08:21 AM
good question :)
agam
,ldh, on Nov 11, 2010 07:33 AM
excellent work
raj
,coimbatore, on Nov 11, 2010 12:34 AM
best article techtree guys ! good work !
pradeep
,bangalore, on Nov 10, 2010 09:55 PM
may be you should have brought in the plasma TVs also in the discussion at the end. Even full HD plasmas are way cheaper and better than most of these so called LED TVs.
Sachin
,Goa, on Nov 10, 2010 07:26 PM
Prices of basic LCD & CRT are almost same now leaving the full HD ones.so point in buying CRT which are short lived.
Krishna R
,Hyderabad, on Nov 10, 2010 07:19 PM
These sort of original artices is what we expect from TT. This article gives a clear insight of what is happening in "LCD LED" Market
dude
,kochi, on Nov 10, 2010 01:50 PM
I knew about Edge lit and Full LED lit TV-s but I didn't know about Local Dimming LED TV-s. Thanks man. It's useful/
kunal
,Ranchi, on Nov 10, 2010 12:28 PM
@Roydon Cerejo, Full array LED backlighting are of two type, "white LED backlights and RGB LED backlights"( later is used in HP DreamColor LP2480zx monitor ). Hope you will mention this in future articles.
Roydon
,Techtree, on Nov 10, 2010 12:36 PM
Noted. Thanks Kunal.
msramkrish
,Trichy, on Nov 10, 2010 12:31 PM
Hi Roydon Cerejo, excellent article and an eye opener! Thanks a lot! Sure this will help people identify and avoid those companies that take people for a ride by their unethical trade practices and marketing strategies fooling everyone exploiting their ignorance in technology. People should clearly stay away from these unethical brands!

Opinion Poll