• Apple iOS 4 Review

    Apple iOS 4 Review

    Prasad Naik, Jun 22, 2010 1618 hrs IST

    We take an in-depth look at the latest version of iOS

    mail share

Expert Review

    next


After more than a month of waiting, the iOS 4 update has finally landed for our iDevices. If you haven't updated your phone already, take a break from reading this and go to iTunes on your computer and install the new update on your iPhone 3GS, 3G or the iPod Touch third or second generation. Because today, we are not going to tell whether the latest update for the iOS devices is worth downloading or not; the fact that it's great is given. We are just going to describe some of the new features that it brings in and it would be that much more easier to understand for you if you have a device ready with you, full updated as you read this. So, let us begin.

(From hereon, whenever we mention the iPhone, we are talking about the iOS devices excluding the iPad, unless mentioned specifically otherwise).


Multitasking:

After three years of coming up with its first iPhone, Apple has finally implemented multitasking in its mobile operating system. However, unlike Apple's desktop version, it works in a slightly different way. Apple prioritized device performance and battery life, which meant traditional means of multitasking could not be applied. In Apple's implementation, apps do not continue to run when they go in background. They merely suspend their activity until they are called back again. With a little something called Fast App Switching, applications are able to save their state and resume from that exact point where they stopped. If it is a game, it will even give you a little countdown before it starts again. Of course, the way the app resumes is completely dependent on how the developer implements the feature in his apps. Yes, multitasking on the iOS 4 is application dependent and if the developer does not take the effort to take advantage of the new API's that Apple is providing him then resuming that particular app would be no different than starting it from scratch.



Switching between apps on the iPhone can be done by double tapping the home button. I prefer this method to the press and hold method that other mobile platforms such as Symbian or Android implement. I'd rather press a button twice, thrice even if required but I hate having to press and hold, waiting for something to happen. Of course this also means that you can no longer assign a particular task to be performed when you double tap the home button as before (this function is still available though to iPhone 3G and iPod touch second generation devices as they lack multitasking).

When you double tap the Home button, the screen slides up, revealing a row of icons. These are the apps that are running in the background. You can swipe right to see more icons. However, we would have preferred if instead of arranging the icons horizontally and then swiping through them continuously, which can be quite tiring if a lot of them are running simultaneously (which is quite likely to happen), the icons had instead been stacked vertically in a grid, so they would have been quicker to access.

You can quit and application if you want to. Just press and hold and then the icons will start to wiggle and a minus sign will appear on them.


 





When you double tap to bring up the screen of running apps, the first screen that is shown is actually the second screen. The first screen is permanently assigned to the iPod application and the music playback keys. Also something that I've been wanting ever since I started using an iPhone: an orientation lock switch. The iPhone or iPod touch may not have a hardware button like the iPad, but this software switch is also good enough. However, unlike the iPad's switch it cannot lock the display in any orientation but just portrait mode. Unfortunately, the orientation lock switch is not available for the iPhone 3G and iPod touch second generation users, which is just ridiculous. Apple could have easily put that option somewhere in the settings menu and it would have still been fine compared to not having it at all.

Finally, there are the music keys, which actually can be used for any application that may be playing audio at the moment and not just the iPod player. They are quite handy, however, as I mentioned before, if you are not near the first group of apps on the multitasking row, you will have to swipe several times before you can reach them. The icon for the iPod app is also found here, which I thought was a bit unnecessary as the icon is already present in the list of running applications when the music is playing.

Another weird thing is that the row of icons in the multitasking tray only appear in portrait mode. So, if you rotate the phone in landscape orientation the icons do not rotate.


 


 



Unfortunately, multitasking is not available on iPhone 3G and iPod touch second generation. This is kind of a bummer for a lot of people out there. I'm sure both these devices could have pulled it off and even though the experience wouldn't have been as smooth as on the 3GS or the third generation iPod touch. But that's the thing with Apple; it's all about the experience.

Follow Techtree on Twitter

    next

Do you agree with this Review?
YesNo

Up

54

Down

15



Discussion Board
(45) Comments
Jonathan
,Marietta, on Jun 22, 2010 06:51 PM
I have the iPod touch second generation. I have noticed it is slower and the battery life has taken a nose drive. I need more time but, I may have lost a fourth on my battery life. This is not good. Thanks for the review.
Sujal
,New Delhi, on Jun 26, 2010 03:27 PM
I too have iPod touch 2G & I feel the battery life has actually gone up even though I have jailbroken it.
John Enright
,Robe, South Australia, on Jun 23, 2010 08:57 AM
Thanks for the article. most informative. my question is: will we be able to have a bluetooth switch on the home screen with iOS4? very frustrating not being able to switch it on or off when entering or leaving the car. i would also like to see more options of creating cross category items - as in MS Outlook where you can drag event to task, email to calender etc - and while we are at it what about syncing MS tasks? thank you
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 23, 2010 09:48 AM
I'm sorry, but no.
George Appleby
,New York, on Jun 22, 2010 08:49 PM
I am disappointed that we don't have a better way to "show-as-read" email messages, other than one-by-one. This is a pain when you are not using your iPhone for a few hours and it duplicates all the messages on your PC. Then you have to check one at a time, instead of batching them.
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 22, 2010 09:03 PM
You know what, I faced that problem too. I think I'll add it to the article. Thanks for reminding me about it! :)
Vikas
,Bangalore, on May 27, 2011 02:15 PM
In usa it is given in 40000 with plan , but in india it is given without plan. we have to give min 600 par month till 24 moths and airtel will give back 300 per month. it is not a good deal.
Julian john
,New delhi, on Aug 07, 2010 09:01 AM
IPOD,IPHONE ,IPAD REPAIRS ONLY AT ZION TECHNOLOGIES(REGD.), NEW DELHI CALL 9810124668---JOHN Jammu and Kashmir-Srinagar, Himachal Pradesh-Shimla, Punjab-Chandigarh, Haryana-Chandigarh, Uttaranchal-Dehradun, Delhi-Delhi, Rajasthan-Jaipur, Uttar Pradesh-Lucknow,Gujarat-Gandhinagar, Madhya Pradesh- Bhopal, Bihar- Patna, West Bengal- Kolkata, Maharashtra- Mumbai, Karnataka-Bangalore, Andhra Pradesh-Hyderabad, Kerala-Thiruvananthapuram, Tamil Nadu- Chennai, Orissa- Bhubaneshwar,Chattisgarh-Raipur, Jharkhand- Ranchi, Sikkim-Gangtok, Assam-Dispur, Arunachal Pradesh-Itanagar, Meghalaya- Shillong, Mizoram-Aizawl,Nagaland-Kohima, Manipur-Imphal, Tripura-Agartala. ZION TECHNOLOGIES 245a,sant nagar,first floor, East Of Kailash New Delhi 65 (since 1997) 41620696//9810124668/9971115336 From Bandwidth to minutes,and everything in between........ HP/IBM/XEROX/APPLE/POLYCOM/CISCO/ MINUTES/BANDWIDTH/PLANTRONICS/ VONIA/3 COM/AUDIOCODE/VOIP SOLUTIONS/SEO SERVICES/AUDIO & VIDEO CONFERENCING SOLUTIONS/IPOD & IPHONE REPAIRSBLACKBERRY SALE AND REPAIRS IPHONE $ IPOD REPAIRS
Piyush
,Washington DC, on Jun 22, 2010 07:11 PM
I just upgraded my iPod touch 3G yesterday. I really liked some of the features; like multitasking is great especially media playback controls, plus folder management is so simple but I loved it because I can manage my cluttered apps into folders now. I can have two screen wallpapers; one for lock screen and one for home screen. Editing playlist in music is also good. I wish same thing could have been done with videos too. I have not looked all the features but overall I am very satisfied as i was looking for the similar stuff before the upgrade. But I would say take a backup before you upgrade as I lost my pictures; fortunately I did not lose any existing stuff.
Rahul
,Delhi, on Jul 15, 2010 02:47 PM
Hi, my Iphone 3G is unlocked ,jailbroked will updating it with OS4 lock my set again to AT&T???
Bhuvnesh Goel
,Hyderabad, on Jun 23, 2010 10:57 AM
You have mentioned multitasking is available in iPod 3rd Gen, but please also specify the specific models ( 32GB and 64GB ) as most users might be wondering why the hell its not working in my iPod 3rd Gen 8GB model.. :( I don't know why Apple didn't included it in 8GB model, its really irritating having the latest Gen iPod but the latest OS don't have all the features for it.
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 23, 2010 11:20 AM
The iPod touch 8GB model is actually not the third generation model but the second generation model. The third generation model is only available in 32GB and 64GB versions.
Sujal
,New Delhi, on Jun 26, 2010 03:25 PM
lol... he was living in the pride of owning an iPod touch 3g... haha, you shattered his pride.
Anonymous
,Mumbai, on Jun 25, 2010 06:05 PM
OS4 sucks on my iPhone 3G, SMS now opens twice later than it did on OS3, Apps open and close slower, When i get into composing message, the composer takes at least 20 secs to open, and then another 10 to allow me to start typing. Very frustrating, planning to downgrade to OS3.
Toine
,Beilen, on Jun 25, 2010 02:51 AM
Actually, you can unlock the portrait orientation lock. Just double-click home button and go to the left. Then press the button on the left.
Imtiyaz
,Srg, on Jun 24, 2010 12:12 PM
Is anyone tell me what is micro sim which is used in new iPhone 4,& hw I used my existing sim in phone
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 24, 2010 05:49 PM
Micro SIM is about half the size of a regular SIM card. It is backward compatible with devices using standard SIM cards and you can use it in one with the help of an adaptor but you cannot use a standard SIM card in a device supporting only micro SIM. You can try and cut a standard SIM to the size of the micro SIM but it has to be done very accurately or the SIM will be damaged and rendered useless.
Anonymous
,Mumbai, on Jun 23, 2010 11:52 PM
Can one upgrade to OS 4 on the official 3GS iphone in India?
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 24, 2010 05:46 PM
Yes.
aruisdante
,Worcester, USA, on Jun 23, 2010 09:57 PM
Two notes: First, the zoom is there fore the iPhone 4, which has a higher resolution camera than the 3GS. 5x zoom on the iPhone 4 is still over 1MP, which while not great, is a heck of a lot better than the ~3/5MP you get out of 5x zoom on the 3GS. They just didn't want to make different versions of the camera app for their two fully supported hardware platforms. Second: You mentioned wondering what the point of having the iPod icon next to the music controls is: This is because it's actually a context sensitive icon which shows what application currently has control over the music controls. For example, If pandora is running in the background, this icon will be the pandora app icon, rather than the iPod one.
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 24, 2010 05:46 PM
First of all the camera applications for the iPhone 3G, the 3GS and the iPhone 4 are different. The 3G's is the most basic. 3GS has features such as video recording, auto focus and tap to focus. iPhone 4 has HD video recording and tap to focus in video as well. They could have easily chosen not to put the digital zoom in the 3G and 3GS. Also secondly, if the icon besides the music button is to denote which app is playing the audio, then why does it exist again with the other app icons in the multitasking menu?
Vijay
,Mumbai, on Jun 24, 2010 11:00 AM
If u are jailbreaking, you can enable multitasking on 3g too while jailbreaking.
Mattanchery Mas
,Kochi, on Jun 23, 2010 01:13 PM
Is Internet Tethering Possible with a BSNL 3G sim ?
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 23, 2010 08:13 PM
Yes.
Jim S
,Elmhurst, on Jun 23, 2010 05:15 PM
This is similar to the implementation of Windows 2.1. in the 80s. Windows was not able to move forward until the Intel processors, starting with the 386 would support this feature. Multitasking is multitasking, all applications continue to run. If this is not feasible to do because of a battery life issue, then it is not. I suspect it may be a limitation of Apple processor used. Hence don't say it is a different implementation of multitasing, it is not multitasking per say.
Space11
,Moscow, on Jun 22, 2010 06:44 PM
Drafts for Messages: iPhone have a draft feature for both: messaging app and e-mails. Please study. Anyway, thanks for article. space11
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 22, 2010 08:10 PM
Can you please explain how an SMS can be saved as a draft?
Dasha
,Kiev, on Jun 22, 2010 10:01 PM
Ты ничего не знаешь дурак!
Space 11
,Moscow, on Jun 23, 2010 10:50 AM
Hi Prasad, you are right in a way that you can't save SMS in drafts as a NEW MESSAGE. At the same time, you can keep in draft your SMS when you have a history of SMS. Simply fill and chose Messages or exit. Later, when you want to complete and send - it's still there. Usually I exchange the SMS with same folks and I didn't have an issue you mention. Anyway, agree with you, to add one more button "back to messages" for new messages will resolve the problem. Cheers.
Ken Thomas
,Acworth, on Jun 22, 2010 06:49 PM
You show an "Internet Tethering" option on the Network page. Understand that the service is "Airtel" but I would have expected some discussion about this and AT&T as this is a very hot item of discussion. Now that AT&T has gone to a data rate plan, when are they going to release "Internet Tethering"?
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 22, 2010 08:08 PM
I understand. But this site is aimed at the Indian audience and for us the tethering option has always been available on the iPhone. Discussing AT&T here won't be of any use to Indian audiences and hence it was avoided.
James
,St Petersburg , on Jun 23, 2010 07:06 AM
I updated my 3GS to iOS 4 yesterday, and I now have an Internet Tethering option....with my AT&T service! Don't know if it will be available on the 3G, though. Tethered my laptop, works just fine!
Jay
,Sonora, on Jun 23, 2010 06:37 AM
ios4 is fine on the 3gs, and in all probability the iphone 4 also, but its even a winner for the 3g. I updated mine today, and am already impressed with the new OS. There are added controls in several of the applications that let you fine tune them to your use. I particularly like the folders application which lets you organize your apps by stacking them. I'm down to 3 "screens" of apps. Much easier to organize, even than dragging them around in the itunes on your computer. It's a no-brainer. If you own an old 3G (for a few more days) then update it to the new OS.
Justin W
,Austin, on Jun 23, 2010 01:29 AM
Everything you said about the home screen wallpaper feature in iOS4 - other than this being a "lame" additon - is exactly how I feel. This is what I have been wanting since the first release of the iPhone/iPod firmware 1.0!
EC123
,Raleigh, on Jun 22, 2010 09:03 PM
The pictures taken using the zoom feature on the camera were clearer than the image on the screen before you took it.
Anurag
,Bangalore, on Jun 22, 2010 08:50 PM
Leaving out iPhone 3G for the home screen wallpaper is another random Apple behavior. Why do they not provide enough information on their decisions?
Annie
,Gurgaon, on Jun 22, 2010 08:37 PM
Any idea when and if the iphone 4 is coming to India? Even with its microsim?
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 22, 2010 08:49 PM
Vodafone had announced that they will be launching the iPhone 4 in India in a few months, although the exact date was not disclosed.
Donna
,Paris, FR, on Jun 22, 2010 07:06 PM
> After three years of coming up with its first iPhone, Apple has finally > implemented multitasking in its mobile operating system Multi-tasking has *ALWAYS* been fully available in the OS. Apple just recently allowed *ANY* apps to multitask. (TechTree doesn't understand the difference.)
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 22, 2010 08:05 PM
I am well aware of that. I was referring to multitasking on third party applications, as well as the ability to quickly switch between them.
Frederik H svej
,Århus, on Jun 22, 2010 07:41 PM
hi! i upgraded my ipod touch 3g yesterday it have 8gb. the multi-tasking wont work and i cant have a wallpaper at the menu! why?
Frederik H svej
,Århus, on Jun 22, 2010 07:49 PM
please answer!
Prasad Naik
,Mumbai, on Jun 22, 2010 08:03 PM
That's because you don't have a third generation iPod touch. The third generation model is only available in 32GB and 64GB models. The features you mentioned are only available in the third generation model.
James
,Northvale, on Jun 22, 2010 07:30 PM
the reason your iPhone 3G is running slower now than before is probably due to the fact that this OS is not optimized for the outdated Apple devices but rather to run on devices like iPad and iPhone 4, just an assumption..
Piyush
,Washington DC, on Jun 22, 2010 07:14 PM
I am sorry. I said that I lost my pictures; but only because I had uninstalled and re-installed my iTunes few days ago. Otherwise it would be fine.

Opinion Poll