Eldar Murtazin of Mobile Review bashes Nokia's upcoming flagship handset
It was supposed to be Nokia's next big thing after the N97 and the N900. It could have had all the features going for it that would have made it the most desirable handset money could buy - but, Nokia has given it away and what could have been a great opportunity to reclaim the "best smartphone crown", now lies in tatters. Well, we're not saying it! In fact, the phone which we are on about hasn't even been officially announced by Nokia. We're talking about the Nokia N8, the much awaited flagship device from Nokia - the existence of which is known to all - with everyone else except Nokia acknowledging its existence.
Anyway, the usual suspect Eldar Murtazin of Mobile Review seems to have chanced upon a prototype or early build of the N8 which he reviewed extensively. If you thought, with the latest Symbian^3 OS and the new features has made the N8 drool worthy, prepare to be disappointed. Eldar has virtually lampooned Nokia and the N8 and has termed the phone to be very disappointing. The drawbacks of the phone range from not so great features and an absolutely uninspiring UI which he says is nothing but a cosmetically enhanced S60v5 UI. On the features front too, the phone is on par with existing handsets. The 12 megapixel camera, according to him, is slightly better than that the one on the Satio and the fact that it supports HD video recording doesn't turn any heads either. HD video recording has been in town for the past year or so. The phone is praised for being extremely fast - but only of you keep its memory relatively clutter free. Once you start filling those flash memory chips, the phone struggles to wade through menus. In our opinion, this bit can be fixed using a firmware update - but then, these issues should not crop up on a flagship handset, even with an early firmware.
Eldar has also said that the much touted HDMI port on the phone is virtually unusable. This is because it is not your "ordinary" port and is smaller than the usual ones and will not work with existing HDMI cables. He goes on to add that he is flabbergasted as to why Nokia has chosen this weird HDMI solution. In all, Eldar has come quite heavily on the N8. While he adds that Nokia will be able to sell the phone - thanks to its advertisement prowess, he sees this effort from a Nokia being incapable of the threat posed by newer phones based on Android and even the Bada OS which have started looking more contemporary than Symbian.
i agree.. Eldar is one of the best mobile phone journalists that the world has seen.. He is not retarded.. Someone who gives an honest insight into a company will always have people speaking ill against him.. I too have used a lot of nokia phones and when Eldar says that nokia is losing out on its top end symbian devices to android and the likes, I do agree with him. for all you nokia fanboys, try comparing this N8 to the samsung galaxy S, the HTC evo 4g(both - android based devices) and even the iphone 4 for that matter and you'll come to know what he means to say.. He's not paid by any manufacturer and gives absolutely unbiased reviews.
If someone is letting you know things honestly, they deserve a little more respect than what we are showing them here in the comments section.. And yes, ihe's reviewed a prototype but its highly unlikely that nokia will get everything to work flawlessly by the time this phone hits the shelves..
Peace!!
Mr Saheb, i agree with U. But what is service provided by Iphone in India. almost A Big Zero. android is evolving, good to see so many apps and quality from the manufacturer. But some of the nokia 's feature are better than a samsung. price and reliability of nokia is no match compared to others.
Hi All
Please consider the following feedback before buying N8:
>Average virtual keyboards
>Unintuitive UI
>Unimpressive internet experience
>Confusing connection management
>Poor social network integration
Rest all fine
Whats the point in bashing a prototype?
Eldar is probably retarded or even worse he might have started getting money from Apple like most of the sites do.
Its surprising how a camera attribute can be considered a major feature in a cell phone. For people who are aware about the limits of such cameras, the XX MP is good as a basic digital camera, unless it can provide u the zoom. And resolution at zoom can ONLY happen with a long barrel lens(optical zoom) , which can NEVER be fitted in a mobile phone. So all the hype about 12 MP camera is total exaggeration. These cameras are only good for basic photography. Adding higher MP is just adding more resolution to normal images. A N8 buyer will most definitely have a separate camera that can serve better than the one with N8.
A cellphone has to have more features to enhance the basic reason for a cellphone. Well if u buy a N8 for photography, I am certainly wrong, but I wonder how many such generous customers can Nokia get.
The different interfaces to the diff media (TV, HD) serve a very niche segment.
I read a lot of comments on how crap the this phone is even before it has hit the stores and it makes me laugh. I do have a question to you Android and Iphone OS lovers out there, is there any special feature or function that is available on your phones (lets put games aside shall we) that is not available on on a Symbian OS. I hear some argue that the CPU is not fast enough. For me this argument is as false and old as the CPU on an MAC is not as "highspec-ed' as one in a Windows machine. Higer CPU speed is irrelevent if the job gets done just as well on a lower clock speed and in this case, the Symbian OS does not a 1GHz processor to do the same job. Some have asked why it did not come Android OS. I ask you the same, why doesn't the IPhone does not come with Android? One more point i would want to add to question comments that the screen resolution is too low for a flagship model. Was the N86 a flagship model for Nokia, I never thought so. It was the best camera phone Nokia produced up to that time (replacing the N82, the previous photography top dog) but it was never in the "flagship" price range even though it was no slouch when HW was concenred. I think it should be obvious when the price was also announced for the N8 that this is meant to be a the best in the market Nokia camera phone and not nessesarily the top of the pile Nokia phone. Perhaps its to soon for the N9 (possibly loaded with Symbian 4) to replace the N97.
Some filthy russians have made some estimations of their own based on completely wrong product is causing the other reporting idiots to run around like headless chickens..:)
It is disappointing as it was supposed to have a 4 inch screen and a 1ghz processor.
Unless they plan to have an N8i with those features.
It misses a physical QWERTY keyboard as well,
HD 720p recording but no High speed recording and again like the N97, a very delayed release.
So he critisies it for using a mini HDMI connector.
This is an industry standard port that is widely used.
I can buy a cable from Amazon for £2.
They may well bundle the cable for free.
"Virtually unusable" - what an idiot!
This is a joke. I have no idea if the N8 is good or bad. But I would not give a dime on a preview posted on some obscure Russian web-site.
The real joke is that many bloggers and tech web-sites jump on the bandwagon and trash the N8. What do they base their trashing on? Like me, they have never held the N8 in their hands, let alone ever used the device. But it must be bad, the Russian says so...
Read the preview on the Russian website on your own, there is just no substance to it. The author does not seem to be a professional and does not seem to understand what he is writing about.
@So Vatar, looks like you're not aware of the credentials of this Russian in question! Eldar Murtazin is well known the world over and his site Mobile Review is far from an "obscure russian website".
You guys don't know Eldar, he is one of the top phone journalists in the world. His reviews are held in high regard and he always gets phones 3-4 months before it even releases to the public. If you doubt him, please use Google to check his credentials.
This is a joke? This is supposed to a model that would be announced in 3-5 months from now, and they say they have already tested it? How does it compare against the 2012 iPhone, they must have tested that too? LOL